Cape Cod, with its stunning beaches, charming villages, and endless summer activities, is the perfect place to indulge in a quintessential summer treat: ice cream. Whether you’re taking a break from a day at the beach, wandering through quaint towns, or simply enjoying the Cape’s laid-back vibe, a scoop of creamy, cold ice cream is the ideal way to cool down and satisfy your sweet tooth. From classic parlors steeped in tradition to modern shops offering innovative flavors, here’s a guide to the best ice cream shops on Cape Cod.
1. Buffy’s Ice Cream (Chatham)
Just a leisurely stroll from The Old Harbor Inn, Buffy’s Ice Cream is a local gem where tradition meets flavor innovation. Known for serving Chatham’s only homemade ice cream, Buffy’s has become synonymous with summer memories for generations of visitors. The iconic shop, with its distinctive building and pink bench, is as much a part of Chatham’s charm as the nearby Fish Pier and Lighthouse. In April 2022, Buffy’s became the proud home of Chatham Ice Cream Bars, adding to its reputation for offering Cape Cod’s best ice cream. A visit to Buffy’s is more than just a treat; it’s an experience filled with handcrafted ice cream, friendly staff, and the lively atmosphere that makes summer on Cape Cod unforgettable.
2. Emack & Bolio’s Ice Cream (Chatham)
Emack & Bolio’s in Chatham offers a fun, funky take on traditional ice cream. With its colorful decor and creative flavor combinations, this shop is a hit with both kids and adults. Try their signature cones, which are dipped in chocolate and rolled in toppings like sprinkles or crushed Oreos, or go for one of their out-of-the-box flavors like s’moreo or deep purple cow. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic scoop or something a bit more adventurous, Emack & Bolio’s has you covered.
3. Short ‘n’ Sweet Ice Cream (Chatham)
Tucked away in a charming century-old schoolhouse on Rt.28, Short ‘n’ Sweet Ice Cream offers a delightful blend of nostalgia and homemade goodness. This historic setting adds a unique charm to the experience, where you can enjoy your ice cream surrounded by a touch of the past. The shop even features a classic old-time jukebox that’s free to use, enhancing the nostalgic atmosphere. Keep in mind that Short ‘n’ Sweet operates on a cash-only basis, so be sure to bring some along. Known for its handcrafted ice cream and warm, friendly service, Short ‘n’ Sweet is a sweet spot where history and flavor come together to create a memorable treat.
4. Sundae School Ice Cream (Harwich Port & Dennis Port)
Sundae School is a Cape Cod institution, with locations in Harwich Port & Dennisport. This old-fashioned ice cream parlor has been serving up homemade ice cream since 1976, and its rich, creamy texture keeps customers coming back year after year. The ambiance is part of the charm—think wooden booths, vintage decor, and an atmosphere that feels like stepping back in time. Their sundaes, complete with real whipped cream and a cherry on top, are the stuff of legends, and with flavors ranging from fresh peach to espresso crunch, there’s something for everyone.
5. Four Seas Ice Cream (Centerville)
Established in 1934, Four Seas Ice Cream in Centerville is one of the oldest ice cream shops on Cape Cod. This iconic spot has been serving homemade ice cream for generations, and it remains a must-visit for locals and tourists alike. The shop’s cozy, old-fashioned feel pairs perfectly with its rich and creamy ice cream, which is made on-site. Try their signature flavor, Penuche Pecan, or opt for a classic hot fudge sundae. With a reputation that spans nearly a century, Four Seas is a true Cape Cod classic.
6. Schoolhouse Ice Cream (Harwich Port)
Not far from The Old Harbor Inn, Schoolhouse Ice Cream is another local favorite that’s worth the short drive. Housed in a charming, old-fashioned building, this spot is known for its generous portions and a wide variety of flavors. From traditional options like strawberry and mint chocolate chip to more unique choices like Cape Cod Cranberry or Maple Walnut, there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
7.Cape Cod Creamery (Dennis, Hyannis, and South Yarmouth)
Cape Cod Creamery, with locations in Dennis, Hyannis, and South Yarmouth, is renowned for offering gourmet ice cream at its finest. Their ice cream stands out for its smooth, creamy texture and intense flavor, thanks to a denser, less air-filled consistency. When you pick up a container of Cape Cod Creamery ice cream, you’ll notice it feels heavier compared to other brands, which means more flavor in every bite.
8.Katie’s Ice Cream (Hyannis)
Located in the bustling town of Hyannis, Katie’s Ice Cream is a must-visit for anyone exploring the mid-Cape area. Known for its homemade ice cream, sorbets, and frozen yogurt, Katie’s offers a wide variety of flavors and toppings to choose from. The shop’s bright, cheerful interior and friendly staff make it a welcoming place to enjoy a treat, whether you’re grabbing a quick cone or indulging in one of their famous ice cream pies.
Holy Cow in Dennis Port is all about creativity and quality. Known for their unique flavor combinations and house-made mix-ins, this ice cream shop doesn’t cut corners. From inventive options like Salted Butter Cracker Ice Cream with Ritz Cracker Toffee Bark to nostalgic treats like Fruity Pebbles cereal milk, Holy Cow offers a diverse menu that keeps customers coming back for more. The experience is just as important as the ice cream itself—made-to-order waffle cones fill the shop with an irresistible aroma, making each visit a memorable one. With a focus on both gourmet flavors and fun, nostalgic options, Holy Cow is a must-visit for ice cream lovers.
For those looking for dairy-free options, Sweet Izzy in Harwich Port is the perfect spot. This vegan ice cream shop specializes in plant-based flavors that are as rich and creamy as traditional ice cream. With flavors like coconut chip and peanut butter chocolate chip, Sweet Izzy offers a guilt-free indulgence that doesn’t compromise on taste. Their commitment to using natural, high-quality ingredients makes this shop a standout choice for anyone with dietary restrictions or simply looking for something different.
Cape Cod is home to some of the best ice cream shops in New England, each offering its own unique spin on this beloved treat. Whether you’re a fan of classic flavors or eager to try something new, these spots offer the perfect opportunity to cool down and savor the sweet side of summer on the Cape. So next time you find yourself exploring the Cape’s charming towns and scenic beaches, be sure to stop by one (or more) of these top ice cream shops—you won’t be disappointed!
